In 2018, a tragic incident unfolded in Painesville, Ohio, when Kayleigh Hustosky fired shots at her husband, Gates Mills police officer Dylan Hustosky, before ending her own life.
The shocking event occurred at the couple’s home, leaving the community stunned.
After approximately 5 years, the tragic case of Dylan and Kayleigh Hustosky still has left many people with questions.
Although the case is under investigation, many people are searching for answers. Some find it strange that how Kayleigh managed to shoot Dylan twice in the arm, especially through a door, seems unusual. Therefore, it has led to suspicions and theories about what really happened.
This article will detail the events leading up to the incident, the incident itself, and the aftermath.
Dylan Hustosky’s Career and Life
Dylan Hustosky, 27, was a dedicated police officer with the Gates Mills Police Department. He had been with the department since 2014 and was known for his commitment to his job.
Colleagues described him as hardworking, reliable, and passionate about serving his community. Dylan’s dedication to his role was evident in his willingness to go above and beyond the call of duty.
Kayleigh Hustosky’s Life and Role
Kayleigh Hustosky, 29, was a stay-at-home mother. She was known for her caring nature and dedication to her family. Friends and neighbors often saw her playing with their 3-year-old son in the yard or taking him for walks around the neighborhood. Kayleigh was described as a loving mother who always put her family first.
The couple had been married for two and a half years and lived in Painesville with their son and a dog.
The Day of the Incident
Disturbing 911 call made by Dylan Hustosky after he was shot twice in his left arm by his wife, Kayleigh Hustosky, in 2018.
Upon the police's arrival, paramedics transported Dylan Hustosky to a Medical Center, where he underwent surgery to treat his gunshot wounds.
Kayleigh… pic.twitter.com/H9BJZt67DB
— Morbid Knowledge (@Morbidful) March 27, 2024
On August 13, 2018, the day started like any other for the Hustosky family. Dylan went to work at the Gates Mills Police Department, while Kayleigh stayed home with their son.
Neighbors reported seeing Kayleigh outside with their son in the morning, and everything seemed normal. There were no signs of distress or unusual behavior.
The Shooting
At around 4:15 p.m., a distressing event occurred at the Hustosky residence on Cedarbrook Drive. Dylan Hustosky was shot twice in his left arm by his wife, Kayleigh. The shooting happened through a door, as Dylan later reported in his 911 call.
Despite being shot twice, Dylan managed to flee the house and call the police for help. He was found across the street near the driveway of Heritage Middle School.
Emergency Response
Upon receiving Dylan’s call, Painesville police quickly arrived at the scene. They found Dylan with gunshot wounds and immediately transported him to TriPoint Medical Center in Concord Township.
He was later transferred to MetroHealth Medical Center, where he underwent surgery and was reported to be in stable condition.
Police Efforts to Communicate
Meanwhile, police attempted to contact Kayleigh inside the house, but she refused to communicate. Given the severity of the situation, Lake County SWAT was called in to assist. The SWAT team used a robot and drones to enter the home safely.
Discovery of Kayleigh’s Body
At around 7:42 p.m., they discovered Kayleigh’s body upstairs with a single gunshot wound, which was consistent with suicide.
The discovery was a tragic end to an already heartbreaking situation. The police secured the scene and began their investigation into the events that led to this tragic outcome.
The Aftermath
Community Shock and Support
The tragic event has left a lasting impact on the Painesville community. Neighbors and friends of the Hustosky family were shocked and saddened by the news. The couple’s 3-year-old son was with a relative in Stow at the time of the shooting, and the family dog was unharmed.
Gates Mills Police Chief Gregg Minichello expressed his condolences and support for Dylan and his family, praising Dylan’s service and dedication to the police department. The community rallied around Dylan, offering support and assistance during this difficult time.
Dylan’s Recovery
Dylan’s recovery was a long and challenging process. He faced both physical and emotional healing. The support from his colleagues, friends, and community played a significant role in his recovery.
Investigation and Speculations
Authorities confirmed that the gun used in the shooting was not Dylan’s service weapon. There were no prior reports of domestic violence at the Hustosky residence, and the motive behind Kayleigh’s actions remains unclear.
The case is still under investigation, and here are details from authorities.
Possible Speculations are Kayleigh’s Mental Health Problems
The motive behind Kayleigh’s actions remains unclear. Friends and family were at a loss to explain what could have driven her to such a tragic act. Some speculated that there might have been underlying mental health issues of Kayleigh that were not apparent.
Many in the community recognized the importance of addressing mental health issues and providing support for those in need. The tragedy served as a reminder of the need for open communication and access to mental health resources.
Suspicious Shooting Circumstances
- Precision of Shots: Shooting someone twice in the arm, especially through a door, seems unusual. It could be seen as either very lucky or very deliberate.
- Self-Inflicted Theory: Some people think Dylan might have shot himself and then killed Kayleigh.
He kept saying, “I was mad at you.” Does this mean he cheated on her and she found out?
Maybe.
I think he was saying “I will stay with you”. Perhaps he was trying to leave her.
yes it was “I will stay with you”
The 911 call sounded authentic….
If he closed the door, and leaned against it with his left side then it could have happened. Think of many of the victims in horror movies. They lean against the door to catch their breath and to gain their sanity. Only in the horror movies the villains have knives, bats, or axes ,but not guns.
Mental health issues are real and scary!
I don’t believe a word of this no one just starts shooting her husband and he said he was leaving her well l don’t think she knew about this, and personally l think he shot her and put on this act of a 911 call. Like if she really wanted to shoot him it would not be two in his arm.
Speculative and emotionally charged comments like this are the reason why “believe all women” just doesn’t work..you are doing harm to your fellow women with your poorly contrived and inaccurate speculation.
I think this was all premeditated by him. He shot his wife then shot his self. Two shots in his left arm, come on. I bet he’s right handed. He set this up and being a police officer he knew exactly how to do it.
See one thing about women in situations like this they are very emotional and vocal; yet you don’t hear her saying anything and that’s because she’s already d—d! He’s screaming and saying things for the operator and that’s it. To make his story more believable!
You hear her say “no” when he started begging and saying I will stay with you please. Listen to it closely
Of course you don’t…. because “believe all women”. Clearly she did it, the 911 tape is extremely telling
Agreed.
The author of this wrote “Meanwhile, police attempted to contact Kayleigh inside the house, but she refused to communicate.” She was dead. How did she refuse exactly? Also, on the call you don’t hear gunshots or her voice at all. He shot himself in the arm after shooting her. Now they are saying she was mentally ill. This is not journalism, its a cover up.
What do you know? A woman is dead and the guy is the victim. It sounds so fabricated to me. Nothing adds up at all.
This “best man ever”, is responsible.
Was that her screaming on the 911 call?
That sounded pretty scarey
So here’s my input….
Neighbour’s saw her that day outside with her son playing, how, when and why did the son get to the relative then? Speak to those relatives to hear what they have to say.
Maybe we could have clarity on what the situation was like when he arrived home from work?
People claim to have heard him say he cheated on her, he begged her that he would stay with her etc, I didn’t hear that at all on the recording though….
The fact that the child was removed from the situation proves this was planned.
The husband knows why! There is absolutely no ways he doesn’t know why!
Maybe post-partum depression?
She was caught cheating on her husband and he tried to leave her. This article leaves that part out
Someone talking through a door and getting shot twice in the arm isn’t all that “precision”. All she had to do was point and pull the trigger. Now trying to shoot yourself in the arm that would be a little more difficult depending on the entrance angles. Some angles could be easy, others would be extremely hard. Then add to matching it up with the holes in the door plus removing those bullets from the scene before responders arrive, would be extremely hard.
Please stop this is my sister she was a strong beautiful woman and a loving mother and faithful wife. This was not planned on her part in any way I had my nephew for a sleepover with his cousins that I had to beg her for. We had plans for the following 3 days together and with my parents. We are still grieving it never stops.
She was not faithful, I’ve seen full discovery and work in the courts, she was cheating and she got caught. He was leaving her and she shot him before killing herself. I understand it’s painful but lying about it isn’t going to bring you closure
Shooting someone twice thru a door isnt unusual thats a weird thing to say especially if he was holding the door try to get away from a person with a gun
Love the women comments lol
You can clearly hear her say no, when he says I will stay with you. He sounds petrified.